Antique Reference Books: Which Ones to Buy

Stack of worn cloth-bound reference books on a wooden table beside an upturned porcelain plate and a jeweler's loupe

Written by

in

Antique reference books come in three kinds: annual value guides, maker’s mark dictionaries and category guides. Start with the marks book for your field.

This guide covers printed books you can keep on a shelf or borrow from a library: what each kind of antique reference book does, how to choose one for what you collect, and how the main mark directories are organized. It doesn’t rank titles or estimate what any particular piece is worth. Value guides tell you what comparable things brought in the year the book was compiled. Mark dictionaries help you put a maker and a date range on a backstamp or stamp. Category guides go deep on one maker, material or type, such as Depression glass or Victorian furniture. A marks book is usually the better first purchase, because a maker and a date are what every later step depends on, from research to selling.

What are the three kinds of antique reference books?

Antique reference books split into value guides, mark dictionaries and category guides, and each one answers a different question. Value guides list recent prices across many categories. Mark dictionaries reproduce marks so you can match the one on your piece, and category guides cover a single maker, material or type in depth.

Printed value guides are a shrinking shelf. Edwin G. Warman published the first one, Warman’s Antiques and Their Current Prices, in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, in 1948, and an annual Warman’s started in 1966, according to Antique Trader’s history of the annual guides. The same article reports that Schroeder’s stopped in 2010 after 29 editions, and that Warman’s (52 editions) and the Antique Trader guide (35 editions) both ended in 2018.

That left Kovels’ as the surviving annual US title when the article ran in 2021. Its 2022 edition, the 54th, ran 632 pages with 720 categories, about 3,000 color images and 12,500 prices.

Mark dictionaries change more slowly. Ralph and Terry Kovel’s Dictionary of Marks: Pottery and Porcelain dates from 1953, according to a Folger Shakespeare Library catalog record, and a mark’s meaning doesn’t drift the way prices do. An older edition simply won’t list marks introduced after it was printed.

Category guides sit between the two: narrower, deeper and usually built around one field, which is why it pays to read a free overview such as the pottery and porcelain marks guide or silver hallmarks explained before you buy one.

How to choose antique reference books in six steps

Choosing antique reference books works best in a fixed order: field first, marks book second, value source last. These steps keep you from buying a heavy general guide that barely touches what you own.

  1. Name your field. Write down the material and country of the pieces you actually own or buy, such as English transferware or American art pottery. A general guide with hundreds of categories gives each one only a few pages.
  2. Buy the marks book before the value guide. You can’t look up a value for an object you can’t name, and a maker plus a date range is what every later step depends on.
  3. Check how the book is arranged. If your mark is a picture with no readable name, like an anchor or a crown, a book arranged by symbol is faster. A name or a town on the mark points to a book arranged by maker or town.
  4. Check coverage and edition year. The introduction should say which countries and periods it covers and roughly how many marks it holds. For a value guide, the edition year is the year its prices describe.
  5. Borrow before you buy. University and public libraries often hold the standard marks directories, and some older titles are scanned online.
  6. Add one current value source. Pair the book with dated, comparable results, such as the sources in our roundup of online antique value resources.

A mistake to avoid is the reverse order: buying a thick value guide first, then guessing which entry matches a piece you haven’t identified.

To compare the marks on your own piece, Antique Identifier – Antiqly reads a photo of the object, on iPhone and Android.

How do the main mark dictionaries compare?

Mark dictionaries differ most in how they’re organized, and that decides how quickly you’ll find a match. The University of Illinois Library’s ceramics marks directory describes each one; the table pulls the useful parts together.

BookEdition listedHow it’s organizedCoverage
Kovels’ New Dictionary of Marks (Ralph and Terry Kovel)1986By the symbol in the mark: anchors, animals, arrows, circles, initialsPottery and porcelain, plus factory dating systems and a section on fakes and forgeries
The Handbook of British Pottery and Porcelain Marks (Geoffrey A. Godden)1968Alphabetical by maker, with an index by initialsBritish marks, plus a chronological list of Staffordshire potters since 1780
Pocket Book of British Ceramic Marks (J. P. Cushion)1984Alphabetical by town, then by factory or ownerBritish marks of the 19th and 20th centuries, with approximate dates for each
Directory of European Porcelain (Ludwig Danckert)1990Directory of marks, makers and factoriesNearly 5,000 European ceramic marks
Marks of American Potters (Edwin A. Barber)1904Facsimile marks with a short sketch of each regionOver 1,000 American marks

Barber’s book is old enough to be out of copyright, and a scanned copy of Marks of American Potters is on Internet Archive. The archive also has catalog pages for scanned copies of Kovels’ 1986 dictionary and Godden’s 1968 handbook, so you can see whether a copy is available to read before you buy one.

For a picture mark, start with Kovels’. If it’s British and names a maker or town, Godden or Cushion is quicker.

Why won’t an old value guide price a piece today?

An old value guide can’t price a piece today because each edition is a snapshot of the year it was compiled. Kovels’ 2022 edition, for example, listed what items had sold for before it went to press, such as a seven-gallon stoneware water cooler made in 1846 at $480,000, according to Antique Trader.

That number describes one object at one moment. It can’t tell you what a similar cooler would bring now, in different condition, in a different place. You may still come across secondhand copies of Warman’s, Schroeder’s and the Antique Trader guide, but since those series have ended, their newest figures are years old.

Use a printed value guide for what it’s good at: photographs, category descriptions and a rough sense of which things collectors pay attention to. For a current figure, look for recent, dated results for comparable pieces, and see how a subscription price database like Kovels Online compares with free sources. If the piece matters, ask a qualified appraiser.

Check a piece against a marks book in three steps

Once the book is on the shelf, checking a piece takes three steps.

  1. Photograph the mark. Shoot it straight on in good light so small letters, numbers and symbols stay readable.
  2. Sort the mark. Decide whether it’s a picture symbol, a name, a town or initials, then open the matching section of the book.
  3. Match and record a range. Write down the maker and the date range the book gives. If two candidates fit, compare the body, glaze and decoration, and read the antique marks and signatures guide for what a mark can and can’t prove.

Method and limits: This guide is a synthesis of Antique Trader’s 2021 history of annual price guides, the University of Illinois Library’s ceramics marks directory and Internet Archive catalog records. No book was reviewed cover to cover and no object was examined in hand, so nothing here is a valuation of any specific piece.

Using Antique Identifier: Antiqly alongside a marks book

Antique Identifier: Antiqly, available on iOS and Android, identifies antiques from a photo and suggests a name, period, origin and a short history of the piece. You can add up to four extra photos, such as the maker’s mark, the base or the back, plus a short note to steer the identification.

If a maker’s mark is visible, Antiqly describes it and gives its interpretation with a confidence level. That helps when you don’t know which section of a marks dictionary to open, because it gives you a candidate maker to look up.

Treat that as a lead, not a verdict. The identification is an AI estimate and can be wrong, especially when the mark is worn or missing, and the price range it shows is based on comparable secondhand listings, not an appraisal. You can photograph the mark with Antiqly and then confirm the result in the book.

Frequently asked questions

Frequently asked questions

What’s the most useful antique reference book to start with?

Usually a marks dictionary for the field you buy in, because a maker and a date range come before any value. A general value guide is more useful later, once you know what the piece is.

Are old antique price guides still useful?

They’re useful for photographs and category descriptions, not for current values. Each edition reflects one year, and Warman’s, Schroeder’s and the Antique Trader guide have all stopped publishing.

Can I read antique reference books without buying them?

Often, yes. Edwin A. Barber’s 1904 Marks of American Potters is scanned online, and university and public libraries often hold marks directories by Godden, Cushion and the Kovels. Check your library catalog before you buy.

Download Antique Identifier App
Scan to Download
Identify antiques instantly with AI
Free to download
🔍 IDENTIFY NOW 🔍 IDENTIFY NOW